MUR Posted May 26, 2020 Report Posted May 26, 2020 Hi Again again,............. Periodically it has appeared in this forum, the subject of criticism of the works presented and after some interventions, it disappears again. For those who have seen my post "Spring", they will understand what I mean. I want all those who want to give me their opinion about the possibility of having a section in the forum, for those who consider it positive to receive constructive criticism. MUR Quote
Rosemary A Posted May 26, 2020 Report Posted May 26, 2020 I would love this feature. It could be a powerful learning tool. Constructive, non judgmental critique is always good. Rosemary Quote
thedom Posted May 27, 2020 Report Posted May 27, 2020 I totally support this idea, it would be very rewarding and instructive for everybody and not only for those who present their work. We learn a lot from each other. Quote
Igor Posted May 27, 2020 Report Posted May 27, 2020 Hi, I can start a poll for members regarding a new section on the forum. Please suggest: 1. A text of question for this poll. 2. Variants of answers. 3. Suggested name for this new section of the forum. Quote
Tonton Bruno Posted May 27, 2020 Report Posted May 27, 2020 I fully support this project. We need something different from a tutorial, just a space to share tips or present complex animations in a dead end in order to find solutions Quote
Rosemary A Posted May 27, 2020 Report Posted May 27, 2020 My suggestion for a name for the new section would be something like "Shows, Tips and Constructive Feedback" Rosemary Quote
stranger2156 Posted May 27, 2020 Report Posted May 27, 2020 I don’t understand the very need to create a separate section or something else for constructive comments on user work. But is it that the topics in which each work is presented are not suitable for this? The author presents his work in a separate topic, others look at it and leave constructive comments (if any). What else is needed? I do not catch the point in some additional platform for constructive comments. Indeed, in any case, we will need the subject of discussion for comments ... will we duplicate the topics presented or dump everything into one topic? Quote
MUR Posted May 27, 2020 Author Report Posted May 27, 2020 Hi stranger2156 The problem is that some people present their work as finished projects and don't like criticism, so you never know if making a comment can be taken wrong. In other forums, there is a section for reviews and when it is finished it is passed to final projects section and that works very well. If somebody has a final project, post it and can skip this section MUR Quote
thedom Posted May 27, 2020 Report Posted May 27, 2020 16 hours ago, Igor said: Hi, I can start a poll for members regarding a new section on the forum. Please suggest: 1. A text of question for this poll. 2. Variants of answers. 3. Suggested name for this new section of the forum. Here is a personal suggestion. 1. A text of question for this poll. Do you want to create a new section in the forum to post you work in progress and receive constructive reviews/help to finish your project ? 2. Variants of answers. I don't think it's necessary Why not, but I'm not sure I will visit it Yes, I fully support this project ! Why doesn't it exist yet ?! What's PTE AV Studio ? ;-) 3. Suggested name for this new section of the forum. I suggest "Work in progress - reviews/help wanted" In my opinion, it would be not a section for tips (but it's only MY opinion). Quote
MUR Posted May 27, 2020 Author Report Posted May 27, 2020 Hi thedom That is exactly my idea MUR Quote
stranger2156 Posted May 28, 2020 Report Posted May 28, 2020 10 hours ago, MUR said: In other forums, there is a section for reviews and when it is finished it is passed to final projects section and that works very well. Hi, MUR Now your idea becomes clear to me. Receive constructive comments and suggestions in the process of creating a presentation. Well, such an idea has a right to exist, it is difficult for me to judge how relevant it is to this forum. There is something similar on my forum, but not for constructive criticism, but in the form of an appeal to the community to help or advise in something. When the author is not sure of his abilities to cope with something on his own. Regards Paul Quote
MUR Posted May 28, 2020 Author Report Posted May 28, 2020 Hi Constructive criticism, opinions (which can be freely accepted or not), request for help during the intermediate stages of a project and related topics, in an atmosphere of conversations between friends. More than 300 people have seen this post, please give your opinion, any opinion. MUR Quote
goddi Posted May 28, 2020 Report Posted May 28, 2020 Yea, I like the 'work in progress' approach so it is clearly a request for critique or help. Gary Quote
Aleina Show Posted May 28, 2020 Report Posted May 28, 2020 I fully support the creation of this topic. And I agree with the proposals of thedom. Aleina Quote
jkb Posted May 28, 2020 Report Posted May 28, 2020 At our AV group meetings we have sessions for work in progress. People can show their projects for constructive comments and help. They are very useful. I support the suggestion of a separate section for this purpose. Jill Quote
Igor Posted May 30, 2020 Report Posted May 30, 2020 Hi, I created a new section on the forum: Work in Progress Shows, Tips and Constructive Feedback https://www.pteavstudio.com/forums/forum/83-work-in-progress/ I welcome any suggestion to correct the name and the description. Also remind a list of existing topics which can be moved to the new section. Quote
wideangle Posted May 30, 2020 Report Posted May 30, 2020 Igor Thanks for the speedy response, as usual, for listening, and reacting to what users are requesting. Regards wideangle Quote
MUR Posted May 30, 2020 Author Report Posted May 30, 2020 Hi Igor Many, many, many thanks for always being attentive to the wishes (too many) of the users of your wonderful program. Thanks also to those who publicly in the forum, supported my idea MUR I have some observations. 1- The forum has a small limit on the size of the files and some works are bigger and I don't like the idea of placing them in public places, such as youtube or vimeo 2- In many cases it may be convenient to put the project zip and not just the exe or mp4, so that the details can be seen in O&A. 3- In the case of the project zip, it is convenient to place a copy of the fonts used Quote
thedom Posted May 30, 2020 Report Posted May 30, 2020 5 hours ago, Igor said: Hi, I created a new section on the forum: Work in Progress Shows, Tips and Constructive Feedback https://www.pteavstudio.com/forums/forum/83-work-in-progress/ I welcome any suggestion to correct the name and the description. In my opinion, main title (« work in progress ») is perfect but subtitle should be « Constructive feedback and help wanted ». Quote
MUR Posted May 30, 2020 Author Report Posted May 30, 2020 Hi thedom Totally agree MUR (maybe Works in Progress?} Quote
Alice Posted May 31, 2020 Report Posted May 31, 2020 Hi ! I just saw this thread about the new section for works in progress, even I did not see many content there yet, it looks promising. Looking forward to see some work of you guys to learn a little bit And by the way, thanks a lot Mur for the nice suggestion! Quote
Igor Posted June 6, 2020 Report Posted June 6, 2020 Please write me more variants if a name of this new section + description should be corrected. Work in Progress Shows, Tips and Constructive Feedback Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.