tom95521 Posted April 1, 2022 Report Posted April 1, 2022 From my limited testing AV1 software encoding is much slower than H.264/H.265. Now we are finally getting hardware encoding support for the open source AV1 codec. I hope AMD and ARM chips catch up with Intel. https://www.notebookcheck.net/Intel-ARC-GPUs-trump-AMD-and-Nvidia-with-hardware-AV1-codec-support-as-game-streaming-demo-vs-HEVC-shows.611051.0.html Tom Quote
tom95521 Posted April 3, 2022 Author Report Posted April 3, 2022 My results from comparing encode times using the very versatile Shutter Encoder software. I was surprised how much faster the AMD Ryzen was for AV1 encoding compared to the Mac Mini using Shutter Encoder. The H.264 encoding time is the same. The fastest encoding was 1 min 49 sec on the Mac mini M1 (almost real time) using Wondershare Filmora 10 or 11. AV1 is apparently not supported on the Windows version of Filmora. The new Intel AV1 GPU encoder is supposed to be 50x faster than CPU encoding. Tom Source video 1080p 33 Mb/s 1min 44sec 432 MB Output video converted to 5 Mb/s Mac Mini M1 SSD macOS 12.3.1 H.264 HW 33 sec 69 MB H.264 CPU 1 min 25 sec 69 MB AV1 CPU 16 min 39 sec 67.8 MB (11x slower than H.264 CPU, 30x slower than H.264 HW) AMD Ryzen 2700 SSD Nvidia 1660 Win 11 H.264 HW 27 sec 69 MB H.264 CPU 1 min 25 sec 69 MB AV1 CPU 3 min 8 sec 66 MB (2.2x slower than H.264 CPU, 7x slower than H.264 HW) Update: April 5 I am now getting faster than realtime encoding in the M1 version of Filmora 11. The Sample Project is 2 min 36 sec and the AV1 encoder is finished in 2 min 15 sec (>60 fps). When AV1 is added to PTE AV Studio I hope it works as fast. https://tommendenhall.com/pte/compare.html Quote
Recommended Posts
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.